Navy veteran, Dana Zzyym, a Colorado resident born in 1958 with ambiguous sex characteristics, sued the federal government for refusing to issue a passport because it requires an applicant to denote gender of either male or female on applications.
US District Judge R. Brooke Jackson in Denver ruled the State Department exceeded its authority under the Passport Act of 1926, and barred the department from relying on its binary-only gender marker policy to withhold a passport.
“The authority to issue passports and prescribe rules for the issuance of passports under [the Passport Act] does not include the authority to deny an applicant on grounds pertinent to basic identity,” Jackson said in the ruling on Wednesday.
Zzyym, who serves as associate director for the Intersex Campaign for Equality and sued after being denied a passport to attend a work event in Mexico City in October 2014, cheered the decision.
“It’s been nearly four years since the State Department first denied me a critical identity document that I need to do my job,” Zzyym said in a statement. “The agency’s refusal to issue me a passport has already cost me opportunities in Mexico City.”
A State Department spokeswoman said it was consulting with the Justice Department to review the decision and decide next steps.
The Lambda Legal Defense Fund, which filed the lawsuit on behalf of Zzyym, noted that at least 10 other countries issue passports with gender markers other than female or male, most using an “X” gender marker recognized by the International Civil Aviation Organization, which sets travel document standards. Australia, Bangladesh, Canada, Denmark, Germany, India, Malta, Nepal, New Zealand and Pakistan offer a non-binary option.
Zzyym was raised as a boy, and underwent several irreversible, painful, and medically unnecessary surgeries, before joining the US Navy as a male, according to the lawsuit. Zzyym served six years in the Navy, and after returning to civilian life, realized there were others who did not fit into traditional gender categories, according to the lawsuit.
“In light of this ruling, we call on the State Department to promptly issue Dana this essential document that accurately reflects their gender,” Paul Castillo, a Lambda Legal senior attorney, said, using the gender-neutral pronoun Zzyym prefers.